All-Americans
| Class Year | Position | Year Named All-American | |
| John Gustafson | 1954 |
End | 1953 |
| Paul Quam | 1956 |
Center | 1955 |
| Duane Brekken | 1957 | Fullback | 1956 |
| Bill Winter | 1962 | Fullback | 1961 |
| Mark Aamot | 1963 | Halfback | 1962 |
| Tim Larsen | 1974 | Tackle | 1973 |
| David Mylrea | 1978 | Linebacker | 1977 |
| John Nahorniak | 1979 | Linebacker | 1978 |
| Nate Bergeland | 1980 | Defensive Lineman | 1979 |
| Jon Anderson | 1981 | Defensive Lineman | 1980 |
| Ryan Hollom | 2000 | Kick Returner | 1997, 1999 |
| Steve Ryan | 2002 | Wide Receiver | 2000 |
| Manuel Spreigl | 2002 | Running Back | 2000 |
| Peter Cathcart | 2006 | Offensive Lineman | 2005 |
