Management Techniques
 
  To date there is no technique that has been developed that is guaranteed to alleviate Dutch elm disease. There are precautionary measures that can be implemented and a variety of different types of insect control methods that can be used. The best measure to take to ensure that Dutch elm disease does not strike is to not plant elm trees that susceptible to the disease. If you choose to go ahead and plant elm trees that are susceptible to the disease (Table 7) the following is a guideline of different management techniques that have been implemented in the past.  
 

Table 7. Elms susceptible to Dutch elm disease.

Common Name

Scientific Name

American elm

Ulmus Americana L.

Winged elm

Ulmus alata Michx.

Slippery elm

Ulmus fulva Michx.

Rock or cork elm

Ulmus thomasii (racimosa) Sarg.

Septem ber elm

Ulmus serotina Sarg.

 

Sanitation

Remove all elm wood or dead wood that may serve as a breeding place for bark beetles. The infected wood should be destroyed before the bark beetles emerge. The wood can be used as firewood. Intensive sanitation involving disease surveys being conducted in June, July, and August with removal of the diseased trees within 20 working days was the most effective in a Forest Survey Study. The herbicide cacodylic acid (Silvisar 510) should be applied to cuts around the trunk or injected into root flares when the tree is in leaf (Ecological Service Bulletin; no. 6)

Pruning

When pruning trees showing signs of the disease a cut should be made 5-10 feet away from the point at which visual symptoms are present. Pruning can be an effect way in which to stop the spread of the disease; 87% of the trees with greater than 10 linear feet of apparently disease-free wood between pruning cut and discolored wood were save (Ecological Service Bulletin; no. 6).

Disrupt Root Grafts

Treatment should be performed on trees less than 100 feet apart. The easiest way in which to treat the soil around trees that have been infected is to drill a series of holes 1 inch in diameter, 15 inches deep, and 6 to 9 inches apart in a line that extends from the diseased tree to any healthy elms surrounding it within the 100 foot radius. Fill these holes with 1 part SMDC (Vapam) and 3 parts water to within 2 inches of the soil surface. This treatment should be done when soil temperatures are above 50 °F and within 2 weeks before the diseased elm is removed.

Another alternative to disrupt root grafts is digging a trench 36-40 inches deep between the trees. The idea is that the majority of sizeable roots will be severed at these depths (Ecological Service Bulletin; no 6).

Insect Control

Different types of insect controls exist that are considered to be biological controls not insecticides. The majority of these are funnel trap baits. These traps are placed on the tree using pheromones such as Ips typographus, a -pinene and ethanol, and methylbutenol. Other biological controls include sticky paper traps which are sprayed with an European elm bark beetle attractant (Ecological Service Bulletin; no 6).

Insecticides

DDT was used after World War II as the most effective eradication method of Dutch elm disease (Wurster and Wurster, 1965), however, today there a number of other insecticides which can be used after the prohibition of DDT in 1968.The most commonly used insecticide is Methoxychlor which is applied as an emulsifiable concentrate with either a mist blower or hydraulic sprayer. The application should take place in late winter or early spring when the temperature is above 32 °F and wind speeds are less than 5 MPH. The coverage of the trees determines how much of an affect the insecticide will have on the elm trees (Ecological Service Bulletin; no. 6)

Fungicides

Two types of fungicides used are Propiconazole (Alamo) and thiabendazole (Arbotect 20S). These fungicides are injected into the tree trunk or flare roots. They can be used for preventative treatments with injections taking place every 2 to 3 years in the spring after the tree has leafed (Ascerno and Wawrynski). To re-inject drill holes that are two to three inches from the original holes and then proceed to inject with the fungicide. If the tree has already contracted Dutch elm disease it is only recommended to use these treatments if no more than 5% to 10% of the crown is wilted and only if the sysmptoms appear after July 1 st (Stennes et. Al. 1984).

Resistant Elms

There are a few hybrids that are on the market, however, the following is a list of elms that are resistant to Dutch elm disease.

Common Name

Scientific Name

Smooth-leaved elm

Ulmus carpinifolia

Dutch elm

Ulmus x hollandica Mill. (Ulmus carpinifolia x Ulmus glabra)

Chinese elm

Ulmus parvifolia Jacq.

Siberian elm

Ulmus pumila L.

Sapporo Autumn Gold elm

Ulmus pumila x Ulmus japonica Sarg.

Urban Elm

(Ulmus x hollandica Mill. X Ulmus carpinifolia Gleditsch) x Ulmus pumila L.

Himalayan small-leaved elm

Ulmus villosa

Cultivars

The best way to ensure that your trees will not contract Dutch elm disease is to not plant susceptible elm trees. The following is a list of different cultivar species.

CULTIVAR

FORM

COMMENTS

American Elm- Ulmus Americana

Brandon

More pyramidal than vase-shaped

Albera, Canada introduced as ‘Patmore’

Delaware

USDA introduction; susceptible to elm yellows

Independence

Upright, vase-shaped; vigorous

Elm Research Institute

New Harmony

Vase-shaped

US National Arboretum introducted. Better from but less resistant than Valley Forge

Princeton

Vase-shaped

Some resistance to elm leaf beetle

Valley Forge

Vase-shaped

US National Arboretum introduction. Shows excellent disease resistance.

Washington

Not clear whether this tree is truly an American elm

Japanese Elm- ulmus japonica (sometimes listed as Ulmus davidiana)

Jacan

Manitoba, Canada introduced.

Chinese Elm- Ulmus parvifolia

Dynasty

Small, vase-shaped

Cross of 2 Korean trees; for plantings under power lines

King’s Choice

Upright crown; yellow autumn color

Zone 5

Ohio

Reddish autumn color

USDA introduction

Siberian Elm- Ulmus pumila

Dropmore

Manchurian introduction; replaces ‘Chinkota’, ‘Harbin’, and ‘Manchu’

Park Royal

Fast growing

Ontario, Canada introduced

North American Hybrids

Accolade

Vase-shaped; deep glossy green leaves

Morton Arboretum introduced; U. japonica x U. wilsoniana; resistant to elm leaf beetle and leaf miner

Cathedral

Broad, vase-shaped; medium to light green foliage

University of Wisconsin introduced; U. pumila x U. japonica; somewhat less resistant to DED than ‘Sapporo Autumn Gold’, highly tolerant of Verticillium wilt; resistant to elm leaf miner

Frontier

Pyramidal; red-purple autumn color

U. carpinifolia x U. parvifolia; moderately resistant to elm leaf beetle; probable resistance to elm yellows

Homestead

Pyramidal; fast growing

Netherlands introduction; U. pumila x other hybrids

New Horizon

Upright; dark green large leaves; gray bark

University of Wisconsin introducted; U. japonica x U. pumila; resistance to elm leaf miner; high tolerance to Verticillium wilt

Patriot

USDA introduced; ‘Urban’ x U. wilsoniana; highly tolerant to elm leaf beetle

Pioneer

Globe-shaped; very vigorous; fast growing

U. glabra x U. carpinifolia

Regal

Columnar; large, dark green, glossy leaves

University of Wisconsin introduced; U. hollandica and U. pumila x U. carpinifolia

Sapporo Autumn Gold

Upright, somewhat vase-shaped; immature tree has vigorous side shoot which need to be pruned

University of Wisconsin introduced; U. pumila x U. japonica; tolerance to Verticillium wilt

HOME