What we can Learn About First-to-Second Year Persisters and Withdrawers from the CIRP Survey and Student Data

Using both the collegeís student records and results from the 1996 CIRP entering student survey, various factors appear to differentiate students who withdrew after one year from those who persisted. For the factors described below that derived from the CIRP survey, the information applies to 48 of the students who dropped out who had taken the survey as entering freshmen.

College Preparation:

Consistent with previous research, students with higher high school GPAs and higher college entrance scores have greater success in college. Of the group taking CIRP in 1996, students that withdrew were lower in both cases. ACT scores also differed between the two groups, somewhat lower for the withdrawers. Buntrock scholars (merit scholarships) had a higher persistance rate.

Preparation in academic areas in high school were similar for persisters and withdrawers in most areas. Exceptions were Foreign Languages (persisters had more years of study) and Computer Science (withdrawers had more years of study).

Students that withdrew rated both their academic abilities (overall and specifically in mathematical ability), emotional well-being, and social self-confidence lower than persisters.

Students that withdrew indicated a proclivity for more drinking, partying, and missing classes, and less studying before they came to St. Olaf than did those students who persisted.

Background:

A larger proportion of persisters had mothers with higher education degrees than did withdrawers. Father's education was similar for both groups. First generation college students were a significantly higher proportion of the dropouts than the persisters.

Two years ago in a similar analysis, financial factors differed significantly between persisters and withdrawers (loans, parental income). This was not the case for this group. Only college finances from 'other' savings other than summer job differed between withdrawers and persisters.

A significantly higher percentage of suburban students persisted than withdrew, and a higher percentage of medium-to-small city students constituted the withdrawing group.

A much higher percentage of students that withdrew were from high schools that had significant minority populations (25% or more).

Motivations:

Regarding their motivations for attending college, a higher proportion of dropouts were motivated by the opportunity it offered to make more money; a smaller percentage than the persisting group was motivated by the chance to 'learn more things'. Similarly, the life goal of being very well of financially was considered very important or essential by a significantly higher proportion of those leaving St. Olaf than staying.

Persisters were much more likely to be attracted to St. Olaf by its religious affiliation, while withdrawers were much more likely to have been recruited by a college representative.

Expectations:

Persisters were significantly more likely to expect that they would study abroad while at St. Olaf.

Dropouts were much more likely to have said that there was a very good chance that they would transfer to another institution and that there was at least some chance that they would drop out of college permanently.


Percent of Dropouts and Persisters Who Had the Following Characteristics

COLLEGE PREPARATION

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
HS GPA: A/A-
50%
69%
HS GPA (mean)
3.34
3.5
ACT score (mean)
24.2
26
Buntrock Scholar
10%
27%
St. Olaf GPA (1st yr)
2.47
3.12

Foreign Language Study in High School

2-3 years
71%
52%
4 or more years
27%
36%

Computer Science Study in High School

1 year
43%
54%
2-3 years
45%
39%
more than 3 years
13%
7%

Self-Ratings of Abilities
(rated themselves above average or top 10%)

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
Mathematical ability
26%
49%
Self-confidence (intellectual)
53%
68%
Self-confidence (social)
32%
44%
Academic ability
77%
85%
Leadership ability
57%
68%
Emotional health
55%
61%

Activities in Year Before College
(occasionally or frequently)

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
Drank beer
57%
42%
Drank wine/liquor
74%
49%
Felt depressed (freq.)
19%
9%
Lost my temper
94%
74%
Overslept and missed class
43%
31%
Played musical instrument (freq.)
38%
55%

Hours per Week Spent in Year Before College

Studying/doing homework:
less than one
11%
6%
more than 15
7%
12%
Socializing with friends:
1-5 hours
7%
21%
more than 15
44%
31%
Partying:
less than one
22%
48%
1-5 hours
59%
37%

BACKGROUND

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
Parentsí Education:
Father-college degree
72%
76%
Father-grad. degree
38%
42%
Mother-college degree
61%
76%
Mother-grad. degree
20%
26%
First generation college
22%
13%
Minority student
11%
7%
Hometown:
Urban
14%
14%
Suburban
28%
41%
Med/Small city
30%
22%
Small town
21%
17%
Rural
7%
8%
Diversity of High Schl.
25% or more minority
21%
11%

MOTIVATIONS

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
Reasons for Attending College
Make more money
71%
51%
Learn more about things
79%
89%
Reasons for Choosing St. Olaf
College rep recruited me
17%
5%
Religious affiliation of college
8%
26%

EXPECTATIONS

DROPOUTS
PERSISTERS
Will definitely or probably study abroad
70%
81%
Very good chance of transferring
11%
1%
Some/very good chance of dropping out of college permanently
27%
14%
Goal to be very well off financially
(ëvery importantí or ëessentialí)
74%
48%