Members John Campion
Carol Rhodes
Steve Rholls
This report is divided into many parts
we first discuss the state of the stated goal and then provide
our recommendations for the next five years. We hope the process
of providing excellent student computing will not be a static
plan but rather change with the changing technologies and enlightenment's
of surveys.
GOAL 1): Review the current computing
facilities and recommend a five-year plan for equipment, software,
furnishings and locations.
State of the Public Facilities:
The operating system on campus is 7.1 or higher on the Macs and Windows 95 on the PC's. Each machine is capable of email and surfing the web. Macs use Telnet/Pine and Netscape. PC's use Ewan/Pine and Netscape. Microsoft Word
word processor is on all machines. Powermacs
and PTM's have Microsoft office installed, which has Word, Excel,
Powerpoint and Access on PC's.
The software on the public nodes is maintained
by copying images of the hard drives from the servers using RevRDist
on Macs and PCRDist on PC's.
Residence Halls:
Each of the residence halls have Ethernet
in the public rooms except Mellby. Mellby is an AppleTalk only
hall. Each room is equipped with several Macs and some PC's. The
student to computer ratio in the hall is better than 32:1, except
Larson at 36:1. See appendix.
The model of Macs are Mac IIsi. The PCs
are PTM233 in the first-year halls and 386 in the upper-class
halls. Hoyme has IIci instead of the IIsi. Each hall has dot matrix
printers. Halls with AppleTalk have a networked Imagewriter. Ytterboe
has a laser.
Below is a table of furnishings: All have chairs to sit on.
Thorson Tables
Ellingson Tables
Mohn Desks
Kildahl Table in one room and desks in the other
Rand Tables
Ytterboe Build in benches
Hoyme Tables and desks
Mellby Tables and desks
Larson Study carols and tables in one room and study carols in the other
Hill/Kitt Tables
Honor Houses:
Each of the honor houses have an AppleTalk
connection to our campus network. The Mac LC has an Imagewriter
connected directly for printing. The machine is set on an Ytterboe
desk. Most of the machines are in the basement of the honor houses,
however several students have moved them up to a different level.
Public Academic:
All public academic areas are ethernetted.
The equipment is distributed to 8 multimachine public labs and
4 stack locations in Rolvaag with one Mac each, see appendix.
The Macs are in the 7000 series and most are 7100's. The PC are
all older Gateways. There are 6 laser printers. Each of the public
academic rooms have built in benches with movable chairs.
Suggestions for within five years:
Software:
_ We
think that in order to more easily launch the mail program and
the Web browser an icon must be placed on the desk top in the
builds of the hard drives. Many of the residence halls have an
alias of these programs on the desk top. I believe it facilitates
launching them.
_ We need to
continually review the software we have available to students.
_ Email is used
widely here but is limited in how it can be used. In order to
facilitate using email for other information exchange, other than
user entered data, we will have to review client based email applications
which handles attachments.
_ In the next
5 years we think that Powerpoint-like applications will expand
in use. Also, the use of Web for students to demonstrate their
knowledge of subjects will also increase. We need to make the
tools to create these projects available. This means greater availability
of picture processing applications and scanners.
_ The use of
other higher end applications will also increase. I believe processing
text will still be needed but integration of images and other
data will expand.
Equipment:
_ We must provide
functional machines for students in public areas. The academic
area should be maintained with the newest technology. With the
redistributed machines going to the residence halls. We recommend
a 4 year cycle to replace equipment in the residence halls. This
redistribution/upgrade should occur to first year halls then to
senior halls. The reason being is then there will not be a machine
down grade as students move from hall to hall.
_ Better printing
in the residence halls needs to become available. We do need a
system to reduce the abuse of the printing. Without changes in
the printing process, the ACC cannot support laser printers in
all halls because of the experienced abuse in Ytterboe.
_ More access
to color printing needs to be available with-in 5 years. This
may be available in the student resource room, concept expanded
below, or perhaps the print center could provide these services.
_ More access
points are needed. In the libraries we should investigate the
possibility of adding more machines. It is in these areas that
one finds the information they are processing, and therefor should
be able to compile it.
_ Ratios in
the residence halls are not bad, except in Larson. Unfortunately
there is no more room in the present facilities. We should investigate
providing machines in the kitchen/snack house in the hall.
_ The other
snack house location where we could have a cyber connection is
the Pause. In the past we have not had room but with the new commons
it may be a possibility.
Furnishings:
Most of the locations are functional with
3 feet per station. Several are small both in the width of the
desk top and under. Also, many are not deep enough to be functional.
Bellow is a list of residence problems:
Thorson has a folding table but should have real table
Mohn with the curved wall we should consider a built in bench
Rand lower the height of the tables
Ytterboe not bad however as machines get larger not sure if bench is deep enough.
Hoyme need to replace the desks
Mellby need to replace the desks
Larson need replace the study carols
HillKitt need to replace the round table
with a rectangular one and the folding table with a real table.
_ In the Honor
Houses as the machines increase in size the Ytterboe desk will
not be functional. The basement locations of the computer will
allow for a full desk however most residents like the machine
moved up but then there is not as
much space for a desk.
_ The problem
with the Academic buildings is the depth as machines in particular
as the monitors get bigger there is not enough room to have the
keyboard comfortable in front of the monitor. We believe the bench
tops will have to be replaced to allow more depth for the computers.
_ Signs in the
public rooms needs to be upgraded. In each location you should
have information about how to get help, perhaps a list of urls
and phone numbers. When the lab is open. Where there are other
labs and facilities if not available here. A place for handouts.
I envision a glass front cabinet which can have signs posted inside
with a magazine type part below for hand outs.
_ In the residence
halls we also need signs for the CA's on duty. This should be
placed in a place where users can see who is on duty and how to
get help.
Locations:
The locations of the public room in the Residence halls is good. However there is in most halls the issue of gender segregation and what floor the computing room is on.
Beyond that issue most halls are functional except Kildahl which is very cramped.
I might recommend we evaluate the feasibility
of putting benches in the room and perhaps removing the wall between
the rooms to allow more space.
_ Hoyme is an
odd room which does not lend itself to many machines. Perhaps
a bench along the east and south ends would help, but I am not
sure if there would be enough space even in this configuration.
_ Larson, to
reduce the ratio, needs another location. As suggested earlier
the snack/lounge may be an option.
_ The location
of a basement for the Honor Houses if it is not a living space
is not conducive to comfortable computing. I would recommend that
locations on the main floor be evaluated.
_ Of the buildings
with a computing lab in them only Christianson Hall of Music is
lacking. The music library area has been taken over by the electronic
keyboard machines, and the CM222 room does not have a public access
designation. This building along with Boe, Flatton, and both present
and future Student Centers need public access points. In particular
as the Buntrock Commons is to be a student congregation area I
believe that it must have public computing areas.
_ I would like
also to have a place where students can go like the resource room
to better serve students with high power applications and software.
This facility would have to be personed to ensure continual functionality
but also with high end applications technical support is needed.
We could migrate the hours of CA's after the initial beginning
of the year crunch to such a resource.
Goal 2) Review and develop plans for
Supporting Students Computing Activities:
State of current supporting of public students
computing activities.
This discussion will primarily address
the Residence Halls student computing activities because the academic
areas are supported through calls to Hotline and hardware support
through Computing Repair Services. The other aspect of student
computing activities is student organizations.
Each of the halls have ether capability
except Mellby which is Appletalk only. Several of the halls also
have AppleTalk connections (Thorson, Rand, Ytterboe, Mellby, and
Larson). Each of the ether halls have a port to a pillow except
Thorson and Rand which have a port to two pillows. Port to a pillow
term refers to the fact that each roommate in a residence can
have an ethernet connection.
The Students are supported by the Computing
Assistants (CA). They are available from 7-11 Sunday through Thursday.
Problem reporting can be done by email to hall-ca alias, email
or personal walk in when CA is on duty.
For each hall there is a Head CA. This person is charged with the coordination of solutions of the problems which come in. There are many management methods
employed by the Head CA's. Some process
each problem report and distribute it to the an appropriate CA,
while others just verify that the CA's have effected response
to problems. Before school starts the head CA's return for training
and assisting with the first year connections.
There is a Head Head CA which watches all
email and can provide expert suggestions to issues being discussed
by the CA's. This person also does spot checks of shift attendance
of the CA's.
At present the CA's log in each shift they
do on a log sheet. This sheet can be used to verify shift attendance
and track problems for the next CA on duty. At the time of this
report analysis of the data was not complete.
Some interesting observations about the
program is that after the initial frenzy of people getting on
line the CA's during Sem II are rather idle. They are not being
utilized to assist with other activities. Unfortunately many people
do not know they exist, which is strange because if they went
to the public lab they would see the signs.
Last summer information sheets for PC,
Macs and dorm info where made. These sheets may have helped a
lot to answer questions. At the beginning of the year they where
placed under each residence door. The PC and Mac Sheets were a
troubleshooting guide talking about common hardware and software
problems. They also addressed some of the issues of printing.
The dorm info sheet informed users about computing resources and
help first in their halls and also in the academic buildings.
It also informed about the St. Olaf Book Store and Computer Repairs
using Advantage One.
A major aspect of Residence support is
the process of networking. Starting first with the application
process. The on line process of filling out a web form was under
utilized. Only 81 of the 1012 applications came in that way. Most
were hand written and then needed to be entered into the database.
As applications were entered appletalk terminators were sent out.
On Thursday net connections were made and users emailed that their
connection was active. Along with the activation email were directions
on how to setup their machines and install email mechanism and
Netscape to make the connection functional.
Lists of students with connections were
distributed to an information box for the CA's. This sheet helps
the CA's determine the type of a machine the connection type for
them to better assist problems which occur.
Of the Student organizations most have computers to help their particular function.
Support for these areas has been primarily
by the expertise of the people involved in the organization.
Student computing Activity suggestions
for within five years:
_ I would recommend
the continuation of the CA program. I believe that it has off
loaded student issues from coming to ACC directly. There is room
for improvement of the program though. Training must be an important
part of the functionality of the CA's. I would like to see spring
training occur to better prepare CA's for the rush which occurs
in the fall. This training would involve reading the documentation
and knowing where to find it. Also the training needs to include
Customer Service.
_ At present
we are working on Web based CA data available at URL http://www.stolaf.edu/people/campion/
follow the link CAing at St. Olaf. At this page is helpful information
for CA's. Talking about the program, how you can become one and
what is involved in being a CA.
_ At present
we are redeveloping the on line information for networking. We
invite you to review it at URL www.stolaf.edu/people/campion /Networking/index.html
This URL is being developed to assist people not only on line
but also people who are starting the process of getting on line.
_ Each year
the information sheets for PC's, Mac's, and Halls needs to be
updated and distributed.
We would like to see the web based network
applications utilized more. To that end we are working on web
based application which auto enters into the networking database.
The form of the application is at URL http://www.stolaf.edu/people/campion/
and follow the link.
_ In the appendix
is a description of the 1998-99 application procedure.
_ Another possibility
of the network application procedure is to activate every jack
in a building. With 65% ownership in the first year halls this
would simplify having an active network jack. At present we are
evaluating the cost to effect such a plan in first year halls.
Over the next five years we would then activate every jack in
the reshalls. See appendix of the cost of implementing.
_ This plan
would also then necessitate the rewiring of Rand and Mellby. Rand
to get a port to a pillow. Mellby is only AppleTalk at present.
Thorson the other hall with out a port to a pillow capability
will have to wait.
_ Over the next
five years I feel that we have to review the use of computers
by the student organizations to best direct their equipment requests
to allow technology to effect the process of their organization.
Support for the organization through the experts involved in the
organization works well, however we should remind them to get
ready for the graduation of their expert.
Goal 3) Develop a strategy for gathering
input on student computing services.
_ I have been
having discussions with the group of CA's about issues that need
improvement. I would also like to investigate the possibility
of a web based suggestion box which would be anonymous.
_ We are presently gathering data about the use the residence hall computing spaces.