Sample Report: Chemistry 111 Laboratory Section B, Spring 1998

Paul T. Jackson
Kristin St. Olaf, Partner
Chem 111 Lab B
Experiment #1
February 13, 1997

Decoding Mysterious Solutions of Inorganic Compounds

Introduction.
This laboratory experiment illustrates how to use the properties of inorganic ions to identify the chemical composition of unknown solutions. Generally, inorganic compounds exist as ions when dissolved in water; an ion consists of an atom or group of atoms with a + or - electrical charge. Often the resulting solution is clear and may possess some color indicative of the compound dissolved. However, when certain combinations of inorganic ions encounter each other in solution, they interact and form a solid (called a precipitate). The formation of precipitates does not happen sporadically, but follows well established rules. One can use the solubility rules and the observed interaction of solutions, to ascertain the identity of the inorganic materials present in the initial "unknown" solutions.

Experimental.
One alteration to the published procedure was implemented. Since reagent solutions were shared among lab members, the solutions were not added in order from A to H, but were added in a random sequence due to local availability. The identity of solutions in particular rows and columns were maintained as published in the lab manual. Additionally, a white piece of paper was used under the 96 well assay tray to aid in determining precipitate or solution color.

Results.
After adding reagents to the appropriate wells in the assay tray, interactions between some combinations of inorganic ions were observed. Not all combinations produced a precipitate or resulted in a color change - both indicators of chemical reactions. Table 1 shows the results obtained from the 8 x 8 grid in our assay tray. Colors of precipitates are noted in the table below (lt = light, brk = brick, yel = yellow, NR = no reaction, -- = ions remain in solution).

Table 1. Reactivity Grid of Inorganic Ion Combinations
Solution
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
A
NR
white
white
--
white
--
yellow
yellow
B
white
NR
--
white
white
--
--
lt yel
C
white
--
NR
brown
--
--
--
--
D
--
white
brown
NR
--
--
cream
brk-red
E
white
white
--
--
NR
--
--
yel-brn
F
--
--
--
--
--
NR
--
--
G
yellow
--
--
cream
--
--
NR
--
H
yellow
lt yel
--
brk-red
yel-brn
--
--
NR

Surprisingly, no precipitate was observed when solution F was combined with any of the other unknown solutions. This suggests that all combinations of these ions are completely soluble in water. The diagonal of the assay tray also serves as a control in the experiment and a base with which to compare other solution combinations.

Discussion.
Using the solubility rules, the list of solutions, and the description of all possible precipitates, listed in the manual as a guide, one can deduce the identity of the inorganic substance in each of the eight solutions (A-H). The approach used starts with the most identifiable precipitate and branches out from there. The brick-red precipitate was identified as silver chromate; thus, chromate and silver ions must be present in either solution D or H. The second most characteristic precipitate was the brown of silver hydroxide. Since this precipitate is the wells containing solution D and C, solution D must contain the silver ion source, solution H the chromate ion and solution C the hydroxide. We now have 3 of the eight species identified.

We can continue identifying chemical species with the precipitates associated with hydroxide ion. Only lead(II)hydroxide is a possible precipitate and it occurs when C is combined with A. Thus, A contains lead ions. Lead iodide is a characteristic yellow color and appears when solution A combines with solution G. Therefore, we deduced that iodide is in solution G. We now know all precipitates with iodide; we need a different solid to sort out the last three solutions. After looking through the solubility rules and precipitate colors, we noted that barium makes a light yellow solid when combined with chromate and a white solid when combined with sulfate. This pattern is noted when B is mixed with H and when B is mixed with E. Hence, solution B contains barium and solution E contains sulfate.

As mentioned earlier, solution F does not yield a precipitate so all species are soluble. This must be the potassium nitrate solution! We have now identified all species by deductive reasoning through identification of the precipitates by employing solubility rules and the list of possible reagents. A summary of the results is shown in Table 2.

Table 2. Identity of Solutions
Solution
Identity
A
Lead(II)nitrate
B
Barium chloride
C
Sodium hydroxide
D
Silver(I)nitrate
E
Aluminum sulfate
F
Potassium nitrate
G
Sodium iodide
H
Potassium chromate

Created 24 February 1998 by Paul T. Jackson

Disclaimer