|
What came to be known as the Black Mountain School of poetry
represented, in mid twentieth-century America, the crossroads of poetic
innovation. The name of this poetic movement derives from Black Mountain
College in North Carolina, an experimental college founded in 1933. By
the time the poet and essayist Charles OLSON became its Rector in 1950,
it had become a mecca for a larger artistic and intellectual
avant-garde. Until it closed in 1957, the college was the seedbed for
virtually all of America’s later artistic innovations. A vast array of
writers, painters, sculptors, dancers, composers and many other people
involved in the creative arts passed through the college’s doors as
teachers or students.
The poets most often associated with the name Black Mountain
are, primarily, Olson, Robert CREELEY and Robert DUNCAN, along with
Denise LEVERTOV, Paul BLACKBURN, Paul Carroll, William BRONK, Larry
EIGNER, Edward DORN, Jonathan Williams, Joel OPPENHEIMER, John WIENERS,
Theodore ENSLIN, Ebbe Borregard, Russell EDSON, M.C. Richards, and
Michael Rumaker (a few of whom never attended the college but are
associated with the college group because of their poetic styles or
their representation in certain literary magazines discussed below).
Many other important intellectuals and artists were also involved in
what amounted to an artistic revolution.
Today, Black Mountain poetry may seem to contain a great variety of
styles and themes. Regardless, there are some common characteristics to
be noticed in this poetry: the use of precise language, direct
statement, often plain (even blunt) diction, and metonymy rather than
metaphor or simile. These writerly tendencies evolved in reaction to
earlier poetry that was strictly metered, end-rhymed, filled with
aureate diction and monumental subject matter. The reaction by the Black
Mountain poets was a continuation of a poetic revolution begun by the
IMAGISTS and later the OBJECTIVISTS. In general, Black Mountain poets
typically refrain from commenting on their personal appraisal of a scene
evoked in a poem, and this strategy can even mean the avoidance of
adjectives and adverbs. As Ezra Pound had pronounced early in the
century (in describing the poetry of H.D.), poetry should be "laconic
speech," "Objective," without "slither—direct," and containing "No
metaphors that won't permit examination.-- It's straight talk."
Besides its alignment with Imagism and later Objectivism, Black Mountain
poetry can be said to descend, especially in its embrace of
individualism, from such nineteenth-century New England writers as Henry
David Thoreau and particularly Ralph Waldo Emerson. As Edward Foster has
written, Emerson’s essay "Self-Reliance" gave the many Black Mountain
poets, "despite their radical differences in personality, sensibility,
and general ambitions, a common apprehension about what a poem might
achieve" (xiii). The poem could be an extension of themselves as
persons, as individuals standing apart from the ideals of an orthodox
past.
Philosophically, Black Mountain poetry also shares a view of
reality—of the physical world and humanity’s relationship to it—derived
from scientific movements of its time, movements that contradicted the
view of a stable and predictable universe set forth by Sir Isaac Newton
and later Immanuel Kant. Olson, Creeley, Duncan and others were
interested in the ideas of Albert Einstein, who formulated the theory of
relativity, and Werner Heisenberg who postulated his theory of
uncertainty relations, especially. Physical reality was relative to
time, according to Einstein; according to Heisenberg, it was simply
indeterminate and incomplete. Therefore, Creeley has argued,
The world cannot be "known" entirely. . . . In all disciplines
of human attention and act, the possibilities inherent in the
previous conception of a Newtonian universe—with its containment
and thus the possibility of being known—have been yielded. We do
not know the world in that way, nor will we. Reality is
continuous, not separable, and cannot be objectified. We cannot
stand aside to see it.
The reliance in Black Mountain poetry, and its "objectivist" forebears,
on direct statement and metonymy is a symptom of this basic outlook on
the world.: What is unknowable finally can nevertheless be beautiful.
This poetry, then, poses a fundamental problem of perception. In "Love,"
an early poem by Creeley, there are the sure "particulars" such as "oak,
the grain of, oak," and there are also, by contrast, "what supple
shadows may come / to be here." These details hold within themselves a
tension between the stable and the radical, the known and the
continually evolving.
The literary magazines associated with the Black Mountain school,
The Black Mountain Review, Origin and, to a lesser extent the
San Francisco Review, were a haven for writers whose aesthetics
and point of view were found to be unacceptable by the mainstream
journals of the time. Indeed, it is within the issue of these magazines
that the Black Mountain sensibility truly coalesces. Edited by Creeley
and Cid CORMAN, respectively, the The Black Mountain Review and
Origin published now well known figures such as (besides the
poets named above) Jorge Luis Borges, William Burroughs (under the name
of William Lee), Paul Celan, Judson Crews, René Daumal, Fielding Dawson,
André du Bouchet, Katue Kitasono, Irving Layton, James MERRILL, Eugenio
Montale, Samuel French Morse, James PURDY, Kenneth REXROTH, Hubert Selby
Jr., Kusano Shimpei, Gary SNYDER, John TAGGART, Gael Turnbull, César
Vallejo, Philip WHALEN, Richard WILBUR, and WILLIAM CARLOS WILLIAMS.
Later issues of Origin, in the 1960s, featured work by Louis
ZUKOFSKY, Snyder, Zeami Motokiyo, Margaret Avison, Robert KELLY, Ian
Hamilton Finlay, Turnbull, Corman, Duncan, Francis Ponge, Frank Samperi,
Lorine NIEDECKER, André du Bouchet, Shimpei, Bronk, Albers and others.
The ars poetica of the Black Mountain movement is usually
identified with Olson’s 1950 essay "Projective Verse," published in
Poetry New York, a magazine that preceded these others—Olson’s fully
defined formula for poetry being projective or open field verse.
In this essay, Olson discusses the importance of composing poetry
according the breath of the individual poet or speaker of a poem and not
according to a predetermined set form of speech or verse. There are two
aspects of a poem, he maintains:
the HEAD, by way of the EAR, to the SYLLABLE
the HEART, by way of the BREATH, to the LINE[.]
The breath of the poet "allows all the speech-force of language
[…]." Moreover, a poem should never have any slack or, as Olson puts it,
"ONE PERCEPTION MUST IMMEDIATELY AND DIRECTLY LEAD TO A FURTHER
PERCEPTION." Hence, the poet must "USE USE USE the process at all
points" so that a perception can "MOVE, INSTANTER, ON ANOTHER." Perhaps
the essence of what Olson is trying to say comes from Creeley’s belief,
as quoted by Olson in this essay, that "FORM IS NEVER MORE THAN AN
EXTENSION OF CONTENT."
The openness of the poetry Olson advocated can be seen in Duncan’s
poem, "Often I Am Permitted to Return to a Meadow," which begins his
volume of poetry entitled, fittingly, The Opening of the Field.
In this poem Duncan is involved with the personal creative process and
the bid for freedom that poetry (and implicitly Black Mountain poetry)
makes possible; writing is a "place of first permission," Duncan
asserts. The meadow referred to in the poem’s title is possibly real,
tangible, yet it exists, more importantly, "as if it were a scene
made-up by the mind"; still, it is a place apart from the poem’s persona
and in fact it is "a made place, created by light / wherefrom the
shadows that are forms fall." Duncan’s vision of poetic reality is akin,
it seems, to a classically Platonic view of the world in which ideal
forms reside beyond human perception, with the things humanity can know
similar to them but not perfectly the same, much as shadows of objects
are like the objects themselves. The point here is that we suppose
places we inhabit "as if […] certain bounds [could] hold against
chaos" (emphasis added), and therefore the poem stresses how very
delicate perception is, and underscores the individual’s seeing.
Likewise, Olson creates, in his epic work The Maximus Poems, a
towering epic persona, Maximus, who looks out upon a vast geography
informed by a historical past. The singularity of this figure is meant
to compare with the immensity of Olson’s subject, the terrain beneath
Maximus’ feet grounded in Gloucester, Massachusetts, and the history
beginning in ancient Greece and running up through a present American
time. There is tangibility, as when Maximus says that there are "facts,
to be dealt with"; on the other hand, he asks, "that which matters, that
which insists, that which will last, / that! o my people, where shall
you find it, how, where"? In Olson’s work readers discover an
astonishing sweep of history, a breadth of vision, and the eternal
verities laid out before us—yet these truths are tried by Olson, tested,
and finally undone. Olson is reconceiving both space (physical
geography) and time (the history of his civilization) according the new
paradigms set forth by Emerson and Thoreau, Einstein and Heisenberg. Yet
this grasp doesn’t neglect the eternally human condition, and accounts
for death and suffering as well as triumph and splendor. Hence, in "The
Kingfishers," he observes that human beings are capable of precision:
"The factors are / in the animal and/or the machine […]"; they "involve
[….] a discrete or continuous sequence of measurable events distributed
in time […]." All the same, Olson says that what endures is change
itself, a theme he strikes at the poem’s outset and reprises throughout.
"What does not change / is the will to change." This concept is
perceivable in all things: "hear, where the dry blood talks / where the
old appetite walks […]."
Olson’s point of view is echoed in Levertov’s work. In her poem
"Beyond the End" human destiny is constrained by natural forces, yet the
point of it all is not merely to "’go on living’ but to quicken, to
activate, extend." The "will to respond" is a force unbounded by reason,
and so we reside always "further, beyond the end / beyond whatever ends:
to begin, to be, to defy." What stands out in both Levertov and Olson is
the precise stipulation of limits and the recognition of something
outside them, which can best be evoked with exacting language. This use
of language is nicely exemplified by Joel Oppenheimer, who was a student
of Olson, Creeley and others at Black Mountain College. Not only is his
work precise, coming out of his student experience; it is also rhythmic
according to the measure of a reader’s breathing, as was stipulated in
Olson’s essay. Moreover, Oppenheimer’s signature diction is for its time
breathtakingly casual and candid, reflecting the social revolution in
America that was to reach crisis proportions in the late 1960s.
Oppenheimer’s poetry is located in the moments of a daily life. In his
poem "The Bath," the acts of living, so to speak, are simple, for
instance the act of taking a bath. His lover’s bathing, Oppenheimer
finds, is a ritual albeit one unremarked upon but for his verse—and yet,
he humorously points out, "she wants him" (the poem's persona thinks) "unbathed";
he is gratified by her desire. The routine of life is celebrated in the
poem by this nexus between the two of them; there is "her continuous
bathing. / in his tub. in his water. wife."
Black Mountain College was the soil for virtually all later
experimental poetry in America and much of America’s later-century art
and music. Grounded in the poetry of Pound and Williams—as Creeley
writes in his homage to Williams, "For W.C.W.," "and and becomes
// just so"—as well as demonstrating great sympathy for the Objectivist
poetry of Louis Zukofsky and the others of this school, the later Black
Mountain writers continued a tradition of exact perception and an
avoidance of metaphor, and of a celebration of the individual that would
also emerge in BEAT poetry. The Black Mountain contribution to American
poetry and poetics was not merely a new version of these other
movements, but rather was original and arguably the pivotal moment in
modern American poetic history.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Carter, Steven. Bearing Across: Studies in Science and Literature.
Lanham / New York / Oxford: International Scholars
Publications, 1999.
Dawson, Fielding. The Black Mountain Book, a New Edition.
Rocky Mount, NC: North Carolina Wesleyan College Press,
1991.
Foster, Edward Halsey. Understanding the Black Mountain Poets.
Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press,
1995.
Lane, Melvin. Ed. Black Mountain College: An Anthology of Personal
Accounts. Knoxville: U of Tennessee P, 1990.
Paul, Sherman. Olson's Push: Origin, Black Mountain and Recent
American Poetry. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State
University Press, 1978.
by Burt Kimmelman, source:
http://web.njit.edu/~kimmelma/topicessay.html |